Best St Croix Vacation Rentals (2025 Local Guide)
Last updated: November 2025. Comparing the best St Croix vacation rentals? This local guide explains areas, prices, and amenities so you can book the right place and avoid unnecessary OTA fees. Use the quick table, then jump to your preferred area.
Stunning beachfront vacation homes in St Croix
People Also Ask about St Croix Vacation Rentals
What is the best side of St. Croix to stay on?
The north and east sides of St. Croix are most popular for visitors. The North Shore has top beaches like Cane Bay and Davis Bay, while the East End offers quiet oceanfront villas and panoramic views of Buck Island. Read our North Shore St Croix guide here.
Is St. Croix nicer than St. Thomas?
St. Croix is larger and quieter than St. Thomas, with fewer crowds and a more local feel. It’s known for uncrowded beaches, snorkeling reefs, and historic towns, while St. Thomas offers more shopping and cruise traffic.
Is St. Croix a good vacation spot?
Yes. St. Croix combines white-sand beaches, national parks, scuba diving, and local dining without heavy crowds. It’s a top choice for travelers who want a relaxed Caribbean trip within the U.S. Virgin Islands. Learn more at USVI Department of Tourism.
Can you fly direct to St. Croix from the USA?
Direct flights reach St. Croix from Miami, Atlanta, and Charlotte on major U.S. airlines. The Henry E. Rohlsen Airport (STX) is about 15 minutes from Christiansted and connects easily to other Caribbean islands.
How We Rank Rentals
- Location & beach access
- Guest reviews & management responsiveness
- Value by season (rate fairness, fees)
- Suitability (families, couples, divers)
Quick Compare: Top St Croix Vacation Rentals
| Rental | Area | From |
|---|---|---|
| Villa Margarita | North Shore | $160 |
| Bit o Paradise | North Shore | $700 |
| Two Palms | East End | $850 |
Area deep dives: Christiansted · North Shore · Frederiksted · East End · Mid-Island
Featured: Villa Margarita – Oceanfront North Shore
Among the best St Croix vacation rentals, Villa Margarita stands out for direct-ocean frontage near Cane Bay diving, easy access to Christiansted (20 min), and rates from $160/night. Kitchenettes, seaside decks, and reef access on site. View details & availability →
Pool and palm trees at Villa Margarita beachfront vacation rental
Villa Margarita – Beachfront on St Croix’s North Shore with easy access to Cane Bay Beach and great snorkeling right off the shore. Guests like its private courtyard and quick drive to Frederiksted for sunsets.
Editor’s note: Villa Margarita is our own property; selection criteria apply equally across all picks.
Best Rentals by Area
Christiansted (Walkable, first-time)
Harborfront, restaurants, tours. Best if you want nightlife and easy access to boat trips.
- Sunshine Cottage – Easy walk to downtown Christiansted. From $270. Near the boardwalk, shops, and sailing charters. Compact, walkable, and ideal for travelers without a rental car.
- Ocean’s Edge – Condo at Sugar Beach, balcony, views. From $250.
Where to stay in Christiansted →
North Shore (Diving, scenery)
- Ocean’s at Cane Bay – Pool, beach, family-friendly. From $800. Elevated perch with panoramic views. A short drive to The Waves restaurant and Off the Wall bar, great for families.
- Bit o Paradise – Luxury w/pool, walk to shore. From $700. Near Cane Bay Beach. Good for divers and beachgoers wanting a laid-back spot with water access and casual beach bars nearby.
Frederiksted (Calm water, sunsets)
- Turtle Cove – Private beach, secluded. From $500. Oceanview retreat near Frederiksted. Ideal for groups and family who want both comfort and privacy.
- Seascape Villa – Ultimate luxury villa. From $1100. High-end west-end retreat near Frederiksted’s calm beaches. Easy drive to the pier for snorkeling with sea turtles and watching cruise-ship sunsets.
East End (Privacy, upscale)
- Two Palms Villa – Secluded, near Buck Island views. From $850. Joe Biden stays here a lot. Private beach and pool with Buck Island views. Great base for exploring Point Udall and hiking the trails.
- Endless Summer – Sunrise deck, ocean views. From $700. Bright modern villa overlooking the North Shore. Guests appreciate the pool, full kitchen, and quick route to Salt River Bay kayak tours.
- Villa Madeleine
Mid-Island (Value, central base)
- Central Cottages – Easy drives both coasts. From $180.
- Farmstays – Quiet, local markets nearby, find on AirBnb. From $150. Mid-island hideaway surrounded by tropical fruit trees. Central for exploring the island, with cooler nights and countryside views.
St Croix Vacation Rentals – FAQs
How do I avoid extra booking fees?
Book direct with owners or local managers when possible; many OTA fees disappear with direct booking.
Which area is best for first-time visitors?
Christiansted for walkability; North Shore for diving; Frederiksted for calm beaches; East End for privacy; Mid-Island for value.
Do I need a car?
Usually yes. Villas and beaches are spread out; taxis concentrate near towns.
Visitor info: USVI Tourism – St. Croix
Choosing the Right Area to Stay in St Croix
Each coast of St Croix offers a different experience. The North Shore has green hills, reef-protected coves, and easy access to Cane Bay Beach for snorkeling and diving. The East End is more secluded and breezy, perfect for villas with panoramic sea views and sunrise walks near Point Udall. Around Christiansted you’ll find lively restaurants, boat charters, and small cottages within walking distance of the boardwalk. The Frederiksted side is calm, known for clear water and sunset beaches ideal for couples or small families. Mid-Island areas tend to be quieter and more affordable while still within a short drive of every coast.
Still comparing options? See our Best Places to Stay in St Croix and Best St Croix Beaches pages to choose your ideal area and villa.