Best St Croix Vacation Rentals (2025 Local Guide)
Last updated: January 2025. Comparing the best St Croix vacation rentals? This local guide explains areas, prices, and amenities so you can book the right place and avoid unnecessary OTA fees. Use the quick table, then jump to your preferred area.
How We Rank Rentals
- Location & beach access
- Guest reviews & management responsiveness
- Value by season (rate fairness, fees)
- Suitability (families, couples, divers)
Quick Compare: Top St Croix Vacation Rentals
| Rental | Area | From |
|---|---|---|
| Villa Margarita | North Shore | $150 |
| Gentle Winds Condos | North Shore | $250 |
| East End Villa (sample) | East End | $650 |
Area deep dives: Christiansted · North Shore · Frederiksted · East End · Mid-Island
Featured: Villa Margarita – Oceanfront North Shore
Among the best St Croix vacation rentals, Villa Margarita stands out for direct-ocean frontage near Cane Bay diving, easy access to Christiansted (~25 min), and rates from $150/night. Kitchenettes, seaside decks, and reef access on site. View details & availability →
Editor’s note: Villa Margarita is our own property; selection criteria apply equally across all picks.
Best Rentals by Area
Christiansted (Walkable, first-time)
Harborfront, restaurants, tours. Best if you want nightlife and easy access to boat trips.
- Historic Inn (sample) – Boutique rooms near Boardwalk. From $220.
- Harbor Condo (sample) – Balcony, easy taxi access. From $200.
Where to stay in Christiansted →
North Shore (Diving, scenery)
- Gentle Winds Condos – Pool, beach cove, family-friendly. From $350.
- Cane Bay Cottage – Walk to shore dive. From $220.
Frederiksted (Calm water, sunsets)
- The Fred – Swim and snorkel. From $250.
- Pier-Side Loft – Dive/snorkel at the pier. From $210.
East End (Privacy, upscale)
- Shoys Villa – Secluded, near Buck Island views. From $650.
- Green Cay Hideaway – Sunrise deck, quiet cove. From $400.
Mid-Island (Value, central base)
- Central Cottage – Easy drives both coasts. From $180.
- Farmstay (sample) – Quiet, local markets nearby. From $160.
St Croix Vacation Rentals – FAQs
How do I avoid extra booking fees?
Book direct with owners or local managers when possible; many OTA fees disappear with direct booking.
Which area is best for first-time visitors?
Christiansted for walkability; North Shore for diving; Frederiksted for calm beaches; East End for privacy; Mid-Island for value.
Do I need a car?
Usually yes. Villas and beaches are spread out; taxis concentrate near towns.
Visitor info: USVI Tourism – St. Croix
