Villa Margarita St Croix USVI

Judith’s Fancy St. Croix rentals

Judith’s Fancy St Croix rentals_ luxury at it’s finest!

3 bedroom, 4 bath, sleeps 6. Direct beachfront, pool.

$1000/night ave.

Judith’s Fancy Rentals

Judith’s Fancy St Croix rentals is an amazing direct beachfront home to rent with 3 bedroom and 4 bath, nestled in the quiet and safe gated community on Judith’s Fancy beach in St. Croix USVI.

Take a cool morning dip in your own private pool, lay around the patio soaking up the rays and working on your tan, or just listen to the gentle waves crash just yards away on your own private beach!

There is a separate pool room that has a full bath and outdoor shower, which is very convenient for sandy feet after your daily walks along the beach.

Step inside this luxury Judith’s Fancy real estate and find everything needed for a relaxing vacation in this very private “home away from home”. Each of the three bedrooms have en-suite, with the master bedroom sporting a very large shower complete with a rain head.

Enter the spacious kitchen and find a cozy wrap-around bar area with seating that opens into the main living and dining areas, allowing your family and friends to enjoy precious time together.

You’ll find this beachfront Judith’s Fancy St. Croix rental offers total privacy for your family and friends to enjoy the most memorable Caribbean holiday ever, while still being only minutes away from a wide variety of interesting restaurants, shops, bars and other St. Croix island activities.

Video of Judith’s Fancy St Croix rentals

Video of Judith’s Fancy St Croix rentals
walkthrough of Judith’s Fancy vacation rental
another video walkthrough of this gem of Judith’s Fancy St. Croix rentals

Large photos of Judith’s Fancy rentals in St. Croix USVI

Judith’s Fancy St Croix villa pool
Judith’s Fancy St Croix villa bedroom 3
Judith's Fancy St Croix villa bedroom 3
villa bedroom 3
villa bedroom 2
Judith's Fancy St Croix villa bedroom 1
Judith’s Fancy St Croix villa bedroom 1
tiled bath
Judith's Fancy St Croix great room
Judith’s Fancy St Croix great room
great room 2
Judith's Fancy St Croix dining area with pool view
Judith’s Fancy St Croix dining area with pool view
Judith's Fancy St Croix villa kitchen area
kitchen area
Judiths Fancy St Croix rentals private beach
Judiths Fancy rentals’ private beach
Judiths Fancy St Croix rentals pool
The pool at Judith’s Fancy St Croix
Judiths Fancy St Croix rentals pool 2
Another photo of the pool
Judiths Fancy St Croix rentals night time
Night time at the rental
Judiths Fancy St Croix rentals living room
The living room in Judith’s Fancy rentals
Judiths Fancy St Croix rentals kitchen
Spacious kitchen
Judiths Fancy St Croix rentals bedroom
Judith’s Fancy St Croix rentals bedroom



  • Linens provided
  • Towels Provided
  • Hair Dryer
  • Air conditioning
  • Wireless Internet
  • Toilet Paper
  • Basic Soaps
  • Wifi speed100+ Mbps (good for 1–2 people or up to 6 devices)
  • Free wifi


  • Microwave
  • Refrigerator
  • Dishes & Utensils
  • Coffee Maker
  • Kitchen
  • Dishwasher
  • Stove
  • Toaster
  • Oven
  • Pantry Items
  • Ice Maker
  • Blender
  • Dining table

Pool & spa

  • Private pool
  • Outdoor Pool
  • Pool


  • Outdoor Furniture
  • Beach Chairs
  • Beach Towels


  • Television
  • Smart TV


  • Washing machine
  • Clothes dryer
  • Iron & Board


  • ParkingPaved Driveway and 2 car garage
  • Garage


  • Fenced pool

Location Type

  • Beach
  • Beachfront
  • Oceanfront
  • Waterfront

Contact details

(Owners: email us to include your property’s contact details here)

Nearby Activities

Nearby places to eat

Location of Judith’s Fancy vacation rentals

Location of Judith's Fancy Vacation Rentals St Croix
Location of Judith’s Fancy St Croix rentals

More about Judith’s Fancy St. Croix real estate

Estate Judith’s Fancy is a district of Saint Croix, roughly 4 miles northwest of Christiansted.  It is located on a previous sugarcane plantation whose great house was built in 1733.  Its surviving 3.6 acres property was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1978. 

Judith’s Fancy is very rich in history, stretching back to the 1650′s, when it was the site of the French government during their rule of St. Croix. It is now a much sought-after location for stately homes and vacation homes to rent.

Origin of the name “Judith’s Fancy”

According to the records, the name Judith’s Fancy comes from Pieter Heyliger, who was an extensive land owner during the 18th century, named the estate Judith’s Fancy after his daughter. History buffs interesting learning more can visit the Estates of Judith’s Fancy St. Croix, US Virgin Islands Historical Society

Judith’s Fancy Beach

Judith’s Fancy Beach St. Croix is located on the North Shore of the island, inside Judith’s Fancy Quarters past the guard gate. Not really good for swimming, but it lots coral and shells to rummage through. Sometimes frequented by surfers, but be careful because it is shallow and has reefs. Some good snorkeling here because of the reef, but only if the tide is down.

Map of Judith’s Fancy St. Croix USVI

Map of Judith's Fancy St. Croix USVI
Map of Judith’s Fancy St. Croix USVI


What are the best vacation rentals in Judith’s Fancy?

There are many top rentals in Judith’s fancy. Here are some to consider, and as usual, Google them by name to book directly and save 20-30% in VRBO fees!

Pelican Heights: 7 bedrooms. 10 beds Sleeps 10. 8 bathrooms. Kitchen. Living Room. Deck/Patio. A large house with four suites and a large kitchen and dining room. Plus two cottages with another 3 private suites. Super sea views, hills, and pool.

Great House: 3 bedrooms. 4 beds. Sleeps 6. 4 bathrooms. 3 full baths. Boutique mansion with historical charm! Each BR has a private bath. Split AC, wireless Internet, kitchen, TV, laundry, and a pool overlooking the Christiansted harbor. Just a short drive downtown and to beach.

Looking for the top-rated vacation rentals for weekend getaways at Judith’s Fancy St. Croix?

I’m sure you have earned a break, so why not take a weekend trip to Judith’s fancy to relax for a few days? A few days of R&R and you’ll be fully recharged. Best of all, staying at one of these Judith Fancy will make rentals will make it worth it.

Sailor’s Rest: Sailor’s Rest is a spacious fully renovated and well-appointed bungalow nestled in the hillside overlooking Salt River Bay and boasts one of the best views on island. This is the perfect spot for anyone who prizes comfort and privacy in a luxurious escape.

Oceanview Condo: 1B/1B newly remodeled ocean view condo, large unit features plenty of space. 50 inch TV, a separate dining area and a desk/work area. There is an outside deck overlooking the turquoise blue Caribbean waters, sunrises, surfers, boats and Buck Island. A community pool for swimming and sunbathing is also just steps away. Central location close to some excellent beaches and world class restaurants. Only 4 miles to downtown Christiansted and 8 miles to the airport.

Where can I find studio apartments for rent in Judith’s Fancy?

We like studio apartments and can offer one of the finest at Villa Margarita. Our best St. Croix apartments USVI starts at only $159/night and have a pool and is right on the beach!

Can I find short term rentals in Judith’s Fancy?

Short-term rentals are easy to find around Judith’s Fancy. They’re particularly useful if you’re on an extended work trip or on island shopping for a property.

Check us out at Villa Margarita with no fees or try Airbnb (unfortunately with fees).

And the best romantic weekend getaways at Judith’s Fancy?

It’s pretty hard to beat the romantic secluded atmosphere you’ll find at Villa Margarita.

Villa Margarita is a beautiful beachfront villa with a crystal-fresh pool and simply amazing sea views. Quiet and secure, romantic and secluded for privacy yet minutes away from all the island’s main attractions and entertainment. We offer individual and spacious suites, each with their own private bath, kitchenette, and balconies offering simply stunning 180° seaviews to watch both sunrises and sunsets over the inviting turquoise waters literally just a few feet away!

Looking for the best large-group vacation rentals at Judith’s Fancy St. Croix?

If you’re a large group, Villa Margarita can accommodate up 10 people.

Where are the best houses for rent with a pool around Judith’s Fancy?

A swimming pool is recommended for your holiday, and Villa Margarita has a delightful fresh-water pool and large sun deck. There’s an outdoor dining area, a gas grill for cookouts, as well as your very own Tiki Bar for entertaining friends and family!

Where are the best large family vacation rentals in Judith’s Fancy?

We regularly host large families up to 10 people. They enjoy the privacy of their own Suite yet the connectedness of being under one roof. There’s plenty of open space and outdoor areas to spend quality family time together in the warm sunshine in St. Croix.

Need one-bedroom vacation rentals at Judith’s Fancy?

Then you’re in luck! Our 1 Bedroom Suite is super popular with guests. It has all ocean-facing rooms with incredible seaviews, a comfortable king bed, and private bat and kitchen area. You can look at our 1 Bedroom rental here.

More videos

Judith’s Fancy condo rental
vacation rental video
Judith’s Fancy St. Croix rentals video

Reviews of Judith’s Fancy St. Croix rentals

Judith’s Fancy St. Croix rentals review (pdf)

VRBO Judith’s Fancy St. Croix rentals

here are a some options on VRBO.

Breathtaking ocean views in Judiths Fancy. 4 bedrooms. 5 beds. Sleeps 10. 5 bathrooms. 4 full baths1 half bath. Kitchen Deck/Patio Dining Area.

Listen to the waves crash in honeymoon cove below, soak up the rays, and relax with your favorite island drink in large private pool with gorgeous ocean views from this home in Judiths Fancy, which is centrally located to the two main cities, and is one of the few gated communities on island. Home has many common areas to share for a large group, but rooms divided for privacy: Main home has 2 bedrooms with 2 1/2 baths, a private detached cottage has two double beds and full bath, and there is a fully equipped apartment on pool deck level. The home also has an automatic generator backup, which ensures uninterrupted vacation time. More info here.

VRBO Pelican Heights Judith’s Fancy Rental: Guest house. 6000 sq. ft. 7 bedrooms. 10 beds Sleeps 10. 8 bathrooms. 8 full baths. Kitchen. Living Room. Deck/Patio.

Pelican Heights St. Croix consists of a large great house comprised of 4 private suites (two upstairs and 2 downstairs) with a large chef kitchen/dining area and 2 cottages containing 3 private suites. Each suite is uniquely designed for comfort and relaxation. Sweeping ocean view, rolling hills, large pool, and dual parking areas. More info on Pelican Heights St. Croix villa here.

Great House – a VRBO Judiths Fancy St. Croix vacation rental. 3 bedrooms. 4 beds. Sleeps 6. 4 bathrooms. 3 full baths. 1 half bath

Great House Judith’s Fancy – A small modern boutique mansion infused with historical charm! 3 bedrooms, 3.5 baths main home now available for rent. Previously was an executive rental and now available to the public. 3 Bedrooms each with private bath, split AC units throughout, wireless Internet, gourmet kitchen, TV, Washer/Dryer, Pool overlooking the Christiansted harbor, grill, short drive downtown and to beach. A classic example of Judith’s Fancy St. Croix rentals. See more about Great House Judith’s Fancy here.

Go to St Croix aiport page

Click here for St. Croix car rentals

Click here to find out Where is St. Croix?

Looking for a good St. Croix Dive Shop?

Airbnb St Croix

Bungalows on the Bay St Croix

HomeToGo St. Croix vacation rentals

Tripadvisor St Croix

Vacasa St. Croix rentals

VRBO Gentle Winds St. Croix

Villa Madeleine St. Croix

Chenay Bay Beach Resort St Croix

St Croix Water Sports

Best St. Croix Beaches USVI

St. Croix Scuba Diving

Paradise Beach St Croix

Salty Pier Beach House St. Croix

Best Places to Stay in St. Croix USVI

Hibiscus Beach House St. Croix

Pearl at Cane Bay St. Croix

North Star Villa St. Croix

Dragonfly Villa St. Croix

Villa Nirvana St. Croix

Yellow Coconut St. Croix

Villa Vista del Mar St Croix

Villa Bliss St Croix

Top of Shoys St. Croix

Paradise Found St. Croix

Pelican Perch St. Croix

Two Palms St Croix

Whispering Palms St Croix

Rainbow Cove St. Croix

So come visit Judith’s Fancy St. Croix rentals in the US Virgin Islands in 2023!